The Barkridges® Philosophy: The Best Available Solution Today. Why Certified Home Compostable Poop Bags Are Our Only Choice

Introduction: The Uncomfortable Truth and Our Guiding Principle

At Barkridges®, we recognize an uncomfortable truth: the perfect dog poop bag does not yet exist. But dog waste must be managed, and we must therefore choose the least harmful option available. Our commitment to creating premium products that bring you comfort, quality, and peace of mind means we scrutinise every product choice relentlessly.

Our decision to make certified home compostable poop bags our only choice of poop bags was a non-negotiable step. It was the result of a rigorous analysis, not just of what's most popular or makes us the most profit, but what current research proves is the best available option today. This article explains our thought process, providing you with the confidence that you are choosing the right solution.

🧪 Our Analysis: Rejecting the False Promises

Before launching, we examined every alternative on the market. Our philosophy dictated that we could not compromise on our environmental impact, leading us to firmly reject these options:

1. Traditional Plastic Bags (Including Recycled Plastic)

Our Verdict: Immediate rejection. This category includes virgin plastic bags as well as those made from recycled content, such as Earth Rated and Beco Pets. While we fully commend the use of recycled materials at the sourcing stage, the fundamental issue remains: the bag itself is made from plastic that persists for centuries. The use of recycled content improves the start of the product lifecycle, but completely fails the crucial end-of-life test. We choose not to contribute to the long-term burden of plastic pollution.

2. "Biodegradable" and Oxo-degradable Bags

Our Verdict: Greenwashing. This is where the deception lies. These products use additives that cause them to break up quickly, but scientific studies confirm that this process only accelerates fragmentation into smaller, persistent microplastics [1], contaminating our soil and water more rapidly. We refused to produce a product that accelerates pollution.

3. Industrial Compostable Bags (carries EN13432 or ASTM D6400 certification)

Our Verdict: Impractical for the UK. These bags are certified to break down, but only under the high heat and pressure of commercial facilities. The reality is that no local councils in the UK currently accept dog waste from litter bins for industrial composting due to the risk of pathogens [2]. This means an industrial compostable bag is functionally an expensive plastic bag that ends up in a landfill, voiding its purpose.

4. Certified Home Compostable Poop Bags (The Only Solution)

Our Verdict: The definitive choice. We chose this standard because it is the only one that is transparent, guaranteed, and works within the realities of modern waste disposal. By certifying to stringent standards (like TÜV OK Compost HOME), we guarantee Barkridges® bags are plant-based, plastic-free, and designed to perform optimally for both you and the environment. The certification verifies the complete breakdown of the material into non-toxic biomass and CO2 [3].

Industry Validation: Other leading eco-conscious brands, such as Adios Plastic, have also reached the same conclusion, focusing their entire product line on certified home compostable, cornstarch-based materials that leave no microplastics behind [5]. This consensus among brands prioritising environmental integrity reassures us that this is the responsible path forward.

---

🗑️ The Public Dog Waste Bin Reality Check: End-of-Life in UK General Waste

We recognise that home composting our certified home compostable poop bags is the most planet-friendly solution, as the material is returned directly to the earth. However, we also know this is not feasible for most customers. Therefore, our rigorous analysis was focused on one essential question: what happens when these bags are placed into your household general waste as well as in the litter bins in parks and public spaces across the UK?

A Critical Reality Check:Professor Mark Miodownik, a leading materials scientist at UCL and author of the "Big Compost Experiment," is a vocal critic of the compostable packaging industry. His research highlights that because the UK lacks the infrastructure to process these materials, the environmental claim of composting is largely "greenwash." He states: "Most compostable plastics end up in landfill or are burnt." [4]The reality is that every bag placed in a public park dog waste bin across the UK is routed into the general waste stream, which means it is destined for either landfill or incineration. We chose the material that causes the least harm in this unavoidable, systemic scenario.

The majority of UK general waste—including the contents of public dog waste bins—does not go to landfill. It goes to Energy-from-Waste (incineration) plants.

Here is a view of how each bag type fares when it enters the general waste stream:

1. Traditional Plastic (Earth Rated, Beco Pets, etc.)

These bags sit, intact, for centuries, contributing to long-term geological pollution in landfills.

In incinerators, they release significant greenhouse gases (CO2​) and toxic air pollutants like dioxins and heavy metals, leaving behind hazardous ash residue.

Our Conclusion: Fails. Perpetuates the problem.

2. Oxo-degradable

These bags fragment rapidly into millions of microplastics in landfills, actively contaminating the ecosystem [1].

In incinerators, like all conventional plastics, the stored fossil carbon is released into the atmosphere as CO2​. The metal salt additives (like cobalt, iron, or manganese) used to make the plastic "oxo-degradable" are not destroyed; they are often concentrated and captured in the fly ash or released as part of the flue gas, contributing to the heavy metal pollution load.

Our Conclusion: Fails. Makes the problem worse.

3. Industrial Compostable

General wastes are not industrial composted in the UK. These bags sit almost indefinitely in the UK landfills, as they cannot reach the high temperatures required to decompose [2].

In incinerators, the released carbon is biogenic (carbon recently absorbed by the plants) rather than fossil-based (CO2​ from oil), which is considered far closer to carbon neutral in the waste cycle. The burn is also cleaner, releasing fewer corrosive acid gases and toxic heavy metals.

Our Conclusion: Succeeds. Minimizes long-term environmental damage by design.

Our analysis confirmed that choosing the home compostable standard provides the maximum possible environmental benefit, even when bags end up in landfills.

Our Conclusion: Fails. Claims are irrelevant in a UK context.

4. Certified Home Compostable Poop Bags

These bags degrade fastest and cleanest in landfills, but still taking much longer than if in home composted. The plant-based material begins to naturally return to CO2 and biomass, leaving behind no plastic residue or microplastics [3].

In incinerators, similar to Industrial Compostable bags the released carbon is biogenic (carbon recently absorbed by the plants) rather than fossil-based (CO2​ from oil), which is considered far closer to carbon neutral in the waste cycle. The burn is also cleaner, releasing fewer corrosive acid gases and toxic heavy metals.

Our Conclusion: Succeeds. Minimizes long-term environmental damage by design.

Our analysis confirmed that choosing the home compostable standard provides the maximum possible environmental benefit, even when disposal is imperfect.

🏆 The Core Barkridges® Commitment

Our train of thought is to offer uncompromising quality that aligns with your values.

• Zero Microplastics: Our promise is a truly clean breakdown that prevents plastic contamination.

• Quality & Durability: Our bags are thick, strong, and leak-proof, designed to handle the job with ease and confidence.

• Unwavering Transparency: We give you the facts and the certifications you need to feel great about your choice.

The final word: While the search for a truly perfect solution continues, current research shows that certified home compostable poop bags offer the maximum environmental benefit compared to all other options available today.

The definitive choice for the conscious dog owner is the one backed by our commitment to zero microplastics and certified decomposition:

➡️ Walk with pride. Choose the Barkridges® Home Compostable Poop Bags that builds a better future.

References

1. Oxo-degradable Plastics Fragmentation: Research on the environmental degradation of oxo-degradable polymers, confirming fragmentation into microplastics rather than complete mineralization. (e.g., Relevant studies from the European Commission or independent bodies on oxo-plastic failure).

2. Composting Infrastructure Limitations: Technical reports detailing the requirements for industrial composting and the current exclusion of domestic animal waste from UK municipal waste streams due to pathogen risk.

3. Compostable Standards Compliance: Scientific testing and certification protocols established by bodies such as TÜV AUSTRIA (OK Compost HOME) or similar national standards, which dictate minimum decomposition rates and non-toxicity requirements for certified materials.

4. Mark Miodownik's Research: Findings from Professor Mark Miodownik's "Big Compost Experiment" at UCL, as reported by Packaging Insights and The Guardian, highlighting that most compostable plastics in the UK end up in landfill or incineration due to lack of processing infrastructure.

5. Adios Plastic's Claims: Public statements from Adios Plastic confirming their commitment to certified, plant-based, home compostable materials that leave no microplastics, aligning with the highest current environmental standards.